Supernatural Selection Episode Archive

Stay a while and listen to these completely free, supernaturally entertaining episodes.

Kevin Hayman 12/2/25 Kevin Hayman 12/2/25

Week in Weird 12-02-25

They’re back! David talks teddy bears, Mike brings science, and Kevin has increasing difficulty with his news sources! It can only be the Week in Weird!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 11/11/25 Kevin Hayman 11/11/25

Week in Weird 11-11-25

Pigs, pigs, pigs! It’s a bacon flavored Week in Weird and the Supernatpod Crew finds the strangest news for you this week and BOY is it a bumper crop!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 10/28/25 Kevin Hayman 10/28/25

The Spooptacular 2025

After a long break, the Halloween tradition returns! Kevin, Mike, and David all ready some old spooky stories and poems and end up destroying ANY sense of mood that could have been there!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 10/14/25 Kevin Hayman 10/14/25

Week in Weird 10-14-25

Kevin, David, and Mike the Throat are back with more strange news including the most fun you can have calling a big foot! It’s your Week in Weird!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 9/26/25 Kevin Hayman 9/26/25

An Upsetting Amount of Hot Dogs - The Distraction Hole

The Distraction Hole has appeared again, this time sucking in Ruthanne from Spooky Dice Bag to join in on the fun. This week, David hosts and we have everything from a camel, to book club ideas, to dancing pickles. And way, way too many hot dogs. All that plus anime, finding joy, screenings on haunted boats, and a game of monkey paw.

This was a long one so we had to use a lower quality MP3. If you would like the higher quality, please consider joining our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/supernaturalselection

Music: 1983 provided by mobygratis.

Kevin Hayman 9/16/25 Kevin Hayman 9/16/25

Week in Weird 9-16-25

It’s complete chaos and multiple character voices in this Week in Weird! Australian Cancer Toes, Biblical Bigfoot, and Lizard Jesii are all waiting for you!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 9/9/25 Kevin Hayman 9/9/25

Week in Weird 9-9-25

It’s the Week in Weird! Mike has news about stolen WWII art, Kevin finds a fake bigfoot corpse, and David STILL won’t let this AI thing go!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 8/26/25 Kevin Hayman 8/26/25

Week in Weird 8-26-25

Mike and Kevin tackle blue meat pigs, the government knowing less about aliens than Kevin, and a website dies in the middle of reading it! It must be the Week in Weird!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 8/12/25 Kevin Hayman 8/12/25

Kevin’s Weird Ass Bookshelf - Aliens Among Us

It’s storytime again as Kevin dives into his collection of vintage paranormal paperbacks and reads selected highlights of “Aliens Among Us” by Ruth Montgomery to Mike and David! Can they survive? Will they stay sane? Who is the young man?

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 7/22/25 Kevin Hayman 7/22/25

Week in Weird 7-22-25

Rizzbot! Murderous dolls! Scary science! It must be the new Week in Weird as the crew discusses the newest and hottest wheat from the paranormal and scientific news feeds!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 7/1/25 Kevin Hayman 7/1/25

Week in Weird 7-1-25 - NuperSachel Collections

Kev can’t speak english and the night becomes chaos as the Supernat Crew finds the weirdest news of the week including survival dog and that ghost hussy they keep talking about!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 6/24/25 Kevin Hayman 6/24/25

Week in Weird 6-24-25

CIA website fronts! Murder Ants! Fake skydiving videos! It can only be the Week in Weird! All this plus Phantoms and Monsters Theater!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 6/17/25 Kevin Hayman 6/17/25

The Possessions of Loudun Part Two: Sister Acting Out

David takes us back to the 17th century to finish up the gory tale of the Possessions of Loudun. Last time the nuns weren’t in it. This time the sexy isn’t in it.

Episode Doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1W8xETzpmpAYv37e2-tvlxMULe9tBPgjiUC4idag12ZE/edit?usp=sharing

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 6/3/25 Kevin Hayman 6/3/25

Reading Derangebow

Kevin and David have dug up some bizarre and outdated material from their archives to read for your pleasure and Mike’s torment this week. Butterfly in the sky? Run while you can.

David’s Materials this week:https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/38067/pg38067-images.html https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/17179/pg17179-images.html https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/58465/pg58465-images.html

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 5/27/25 Kevin Hayman 5/27/25

Week in Weird 5-27-25

Is your week weird enough? Well we’ve got a haunted bus and animals on meth for you! All that AND Phantoms & Monsters Theater!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 4/29/25 Kevin Hayman 4/29/25

Breaking Mike 2

This week both Kevin AND David bring questionable science and theory to the table in an attempt to break the brain of Mike and each other. It’s a wild ride of Djinn and Crystal B.S. so strap in and call your therapist!

Cogito Ergo Doleo

Find more info about the show at https://www.supernaturalselectionpod.com/

Support us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/supernaturalselection

Theme music by FC Music Studios - https://soundbetter.com/profiles/408824-fc-music-studios

Friends of the Show!

Flagged for Content: https://linktr.ee/flaggedforcontent

Spooky Dice Bag: https://spookydicebag.com/

Kevin Hayman 4/24/25 Kevin Hayman 4/24/25

Destruction Derby - The Distraction Hole

Kevin is in the driver's seat this week and hits the gang with a fun game of vehicular chaos. But before that, he talks writing and bad movie nostalgia. David talks about Daredevil's return and the surprisingly uncertain future of 4Chan. Also, Mike talks Reacher and sleepy-time watches. All that plus this insane clip of Captain Falcon: https://youtu.be/OX_jsbdfc6Y?si=MRx04sv5LwlEUNf6

Our theme music is Out of School by Jahzzar from the album Traveler’s Guide and can be found here.Out of School by Jahzzar is licensed under an Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 International License.